Monday, August 3, 2020

Returning to the classroom will be a chance to rethink its purpose

by Prof. Sanjay Sharma, Green Executive: https://greenexecutive.com/front-page/blog-categories/education/returning-to-the-classroom-will-be-a-chance-to-rethink-its-purpose

Returning to the classroom will be a chance to rethink its purpose
Image source: 潜辉 韦 from Pixabay.

The pandemic has forced students around the world into distance learning. This has exposed the shortcomings of both online and classroom-based education. As we get back to normal, we have a chance to combine the best of both worlds into a more effective pedagogical model. Here's how.

COVID-19 has had a dramatic impact on life across the planet, and few things are expected to return to the old normal anytime soon. For education, though, a new normal is urgently needed.

For much of the world, and at almost every level, education revolves around exams. Leaving aside the complex debate on the need and value of exams, an essential ingredient of learning inevitably takes a back seat: engagement. Deep, actionable learning requires debates, discussions, projects, coaching, criticism and feedback. But this is difficult to achieve and harder to scale, and consequently widely neglected.

COVID-19 has forced much of the world into distance learning. Many institutions found the transition to video-conferencing relatively straightforward – as long as students had the networking and computing resources to access the lectures. But that seamlessness exposes a deeper problem in residential education. And for that matter, what we are seeing with Zoom classes today isn't state-of-the-art online education either. Much of the world is caught between two worlds, exposing the failings of both: an educational system that was somewhat socially distanced to begin with, and a distance-learning solution that just isn't built on lessons from modern online learning.

Now is the time to rebuild, and there are three areas to consider: pedagogy, modalities, and structure. The science of learning, rapidly evolving technological capabilities, and the changing future of work all indicate which way to head.

1. Pedagogy

When nature yields proximity back to us, educators and students will inevitably ask, "now what?" The fact is, much of the in-person time in classrooms around the world is wasted in one-too-many lectures that might as well have been delivered on Zoom. Instead, we need massive adoption of the flipped classroom. The idea is to reserve the actual classroom for engaging two-way activities while using online and pre-reading to accomplish one-way transfer. This is not a new idea; many fields, such as the humanities, and many educational institutions – such as mine, MIT – understand that students need to marinate in the content. The science of learning tells us that learning is most effective when students are curious, and dopamine is released in the brain. And it tells us that students absorb material better when they struggle but receive timely coaching, and when they discover and apply concepts. This can be achieved in formal and informal discussions, in performances, and through projects: a robot, a dissection, a piece of software, an independent research study, a musical composition, or a community activity. But this is all often lost in the quest for utilitarian efficiency. A large number of small, private liberal art colleges will not survive the COVID-19 winter because of their much-debated economics. Ironically though, pedagogy is one thing they do get right, and their demise will be a tragedy.

2. Modality

Distance education is not online education. Properly designed online content involves short (5-10 minutes), well-produced, asynchronous videos that are more attuned to the ability of the human brain to focus. Online content can also include simulations, games and online group annotation of a document – which are more vivid than most in-person lectures. Students can pause, rewind or speed up content at their convenience. Brief, auto-graded quizzes after each video enable something known in cognitive science as the testing effect: immediate recall from content promotes long-term retention. Over time, online capabilities will become even more sophisticated with simulations, games and virtual reality. An online student moves to the next topic when she has mastered the previous one. This is called mastery learning and leads to more concrete progress in the learning journey. Online forums are surprisingly good at peer-to-peer and expert interaction. Zoom has its place too in this world: students can use videoconferencing to interact with peers, teaching assistants, professors and coaches. But when the lockdown ends, the online modality should be used primarily to make time for the most important aspect of education: in-person engagement. Online can never be a replacement for good in-person learning but it can strengthen it, improving grasp and nuance. But make no mistake: good online content will replace disengaged teaching rapidly and decisively. And online education certainly offers a better cost-benefit equation than a mediocre college.
 

3. Structure

The structure of education today is brittle. As the contours of the labour market become uncertain after COVID-19, education will need to become more malleable. Students will need more visibility of and more connections into the working world, and more bite-sized options so that they can customize their trajectories. Two and four-year degrees cannot be the only alternatives. High school students everywhere might want to do apprenticeships to get a taste of work, as they do in Switzerland today. Perhaps we need more vocational technical schools, so that students get more job-ready skills. While studying for an associate or bachelor's degree in accounting, a student might want to get a separate online certificate, like a MicroMasters in financial engineering. Microcredentials are in our future. They give students options to tailor their curricula. If COVID-19 has taught the workforce one thing, it is that working adults must be able to acquire new skills rapidly, and likely continuously. This points to the need for new options for continuous adult education. Much of it will be online from the edX and Courseras of the world. Some learning must necessarily be in person – to learn to operate equipment, for example – but it is hard to leave work for extended periods of time. Distilled in-person experiences over a week or distributed across weekends will become necessary. One way or another, the structure of our educational systems is monolithic, and it needs more granularity.

The need for reform

By impounding proximity from human society, COVID-19 has exposed some of the flaws of our education system. Many symptoms were pre-existing: $1.6 trillion in student debt, eroding confidence in educational institutions, colleges in trouble. And perhaps more starkly, the loss of nuance in public discourse, the black-and white positions when shades of grey are required, and the decline of compassion, critical thinking and sensible discussion. If the education system does not reform at all levels, the cold hard calculus of market economics will sweep much of it aside, taking with it the most precious and delicate aspect of education: engagement. We must reanimate engagement in education in 2021 and beyond as we slowly dust ourselves off after this brawl with nature.

********************
Originally published in weforum.org.

Author: Sanjay Sarma is a Professor of Mechanical Engineering and Vice President for Open learning at MIT. In addition to pioneering online education, Open Learning includes the Jameel World Education Lab, which works with universities around the world on the future of education. Sarma is the author of the upcoming book "Grasp: The Science Transforming How We Learn".
********************
Any opinions or views expressed in this blog post are those of the individual author, unless explicitly stated to be those of GreenExecutive.

Saturday, August 1, 2020

The PhD: Searching for research data - navigating uneven terrain

As the amount of research data available increases, searching for research data is one way of opening up new avenues of research. However, it is not without its pitfalls! This post looks at two problems facing the data searcher, and ways of overcoming them.
Research data is increasingly becoming a fundamental part of the PhD process. Funding statements and projects require data management plans that encompass what data will be produced, and how that data will be collected, managed and stored. Funding bodies including the UK Research and Innovation Councils (the UKRI includes the EPSRC, BBSRC and AHRC, to name a few) require research data from a funded project to be made open access.
The rise of open access research data comes with many benefits for researchers. Searching for data can open new avenues of research – sometimes in entirely different disciplines! Data can be used to examine, replicate and challenge research methodologies. It can be used to more effectively understand and support new conclusions or challenge existing ones. Sharing research data enables future researchers to discover new lines of enquiry without the duplication of effort involved in collecting the data again.
But even as the amount of research data increases, searching for this data is not always an easy task! There are two points to keep in mind when searching for research data.
  1. The Location of Data is not always obvious
Depending on where the data was collected, what data was collected, and how much was collected, data might be stored in a generalist repository, a discipline specific one, or an institutional one. Many articles provide links to where the corresponding dataset is deposited, but not always. Additionally, some datasets are not linked to specific articles or publications or are associated with many research projects that do not link back to these datasets.
But thankfully there is a way of finding out where this data might be stored. Re3data.org is an invaluable tool for finding data repositories – regardless of whether you’re searching by subject area or specific research topic. Personally, as a social scientist with an interest in AI and machine learning, this helped me to find repositories such as the UCI Machine Learning Repository and OpenML that I otherwise would have overlooked!
Alternatively, I have found it always worth checking the academic affiliation of various publication authors when looking for datasets that are associated with, but not explicitly linked to, a publication. Sometimes the data has been held not by the Principal Investigator’s University or at the University of one of the top listed academics on the paper, but rather at the data collector’s University.
2. The landscape of repositories is highly heterogenous
Some repositories are data specific, while others store datasets in particular areas or flag them with searchable terms. Some repositories don’t categorise data separately at all, or simply flag them as miscellaneous. Depending on the conventions governing how and where data is stored, different terms might be salient when conducting a search.
Searching for datasets in repositories can require a delicate touch. Sometimes the dataset is listed under a different name to the paper and on rare occasions even academic’s names can be listed differently due to different database conventions, changes in circumstance, and typos (seriously!). As with searching for specific items and combing through other repositories, a single letter can make a massive difference to a search term. If a dataset doesn’t come up the first time, when searching for the exact title or author name, it is definitely worth giving it a go with less information to see if that changes things.
Another thing to bear in mind is how data might be tagged in relation to the University. Although ‘University of Warwick’ seems to be the standard – and most popular – way of referencing the affiliation in generalist repositories, searching for ‘Warwick University’ can throw up different – and equally relevant – results!
With the above in mind, searching for data can be a frustrating experience. But if you can navigate the ever-expanding ocean of open access data repositories it is definitely a rewarding one. A bit of patience with search terms – the keyword ‘data’ or ‘dataset’ is a must – can open up entirely new lines of inquiry. Because of this, it is another great tool to have for researchers.